PublicI am marginally impressed, but no better than that. I'd say it's about what I expected, but not as good as I'd been hoping. Thoughts:
Pros: It's quite nicely laid out, and it's easy to use and to read other people's reviews. I quite like being able to keep a kind of diary of what I've watched when. Its search feature is surprisingly well thought out. Since I've already posted my reviews on here, it's very little effort to crosspost to there. I can also link to those posts without linking to this DW with all its non-film fluff. I'm continuing to use Letterboxd for these reasons.
On the downside, the community features are pretty minimal: the commenting on reviews is clunky and ultra-basic (reply notifications only sometimes work at all) and there seems little reason to follow someone you don't already know. It doesn't feel much like, well, a community. I don't really like sites you have to use for literal years before getting any real interaction at all. And which idiot decided not to let you filter reviews by language? There are some
English-language films where at least half the reviews are in Spanish or Italian or whatever.
Oh, and even if you pay for Pro, which allows custom posters, you still can't display UK-standard quad posters sensibly. (40x30 inches, landscape format – the ones I use on most film posts here.) The usual Internet US-centricism. So I won't pay.
Anyway, should anyone want to see what I post over there, which is basically what I paste here with a slicker look but less interaction,
here's my Letterboxd profile.